Shop scary stuffed animals

Sponsored
$14.99
Horror Baby, Horror Rattles, Baby Plushie, Stuffy, Jason, Friday, 13Th, Halloween, Cult Horror, Halloween, Scary, Horror Fan, Babyshower
Etsy
1K+
$14.99
Horror Baby, Horror Rattles, Baby Plushie, Stuffy, Jason, Friday, 13Th, Halloween, Cult Horror, Halloween, Scary, Horror Fan, Babyshower
Etsy
$14.99
Horror Baby, Horror Rattles, Baby Plushie, Stuffy, Penny, Clown, Classic, Halloween, Cult Horror, Halloween, Scary, Horror Fan, Babyshower
Etsy
1K+
$14.99
Horror Baby, Horror Rattles, Baby Plushie, Stuffy, Penny, Clown, Classic, Halloween, Cult Horror, Halloween, Scary, Horror Fan, Babyshower
Etsy
$16.20
40cm Huggy Wuggy Horror Doll Plush Toy | Blue
DailySale
$16.20
40cm Huggy Wuggy Horror Doll Plush Toy | Blue
DailySale
$99.00
Huggy Wuggy 32", Poppy Playtime Plush, Horror Doll, Monster Plush, Creepy Plush, Weirdcore Plush, Giant Plush, Big Plush
Etsy
$99.00
Huggy Wuggy 32", Poppy Playtime Plush, Horror Doll, Monster Plush, Creepy Plush, Weirdcore Plush, Giant Plush, Big Plush
Etsy
$69.00
Custom Creepy Horror Carebear Stuffed Toys, Horror Plush
Etsy
$69.00
Custom Creepy Horror Carebear Stuffed Toys, Horror Plush
Etsy
$86.70
$102.00
Honeysuckles- Creepy Plush Bear,Creepy Oddities, Horror Dolls, Macabre Gift, Zombie Animal, Creepy Toy,Gothic Toys,Weird Plushies,Scary Gift
Etsy
Free shipping
15% off
$86.70
$102.00
Honeysuckles- Creepy Plush Bear,Creepy Oddities, Horror Dolls, Macabre Gift, Zombie Animal, Creepy Toy,Gothic Toys,Weird Plushies,Scary Gift
Etsy
$48.00
Custom Creepy Horror Carebear Stuffed Toys, Horror Plush
Etsy
$48.00
Custom Creepy Horror Carebear Stuffed Toys, Horror Plush
Etsy
$82.00
Handmade Zombie Bears Horror Creepyart Plush Bloody Teddybear Brain
Etsy
$82.00
Handmade Zombie Bears Horror Creepyart Plush Bloody Teddybear Brain
Etsy
$71.40
$84.00
Chipper- Creepy Plush Bear,Creepy Oddities, Horror Dolls, Macabre Gift, Zombie Animal, Creepy Toy,Gothic Toys,Weird Plushies,Scary Gift
Etsy
Free shipping
14% off
$71.40
$84.00
Chipper- Creepy Plush Bear,Creepy Oddities, Horror Dolls, Macabre Gift, Zombie Animal, Creepy Toy,Gothic Toys,Weird Plushies,Scary Gift
Etsy
$100.00
MADE TO ORDER Creepy Cute Horror Cuddly Plushies
Etsy
$100.00
MADE TO ORDER Creepy Cute Horror Cuddly Plushies
Etsy
$69.00
$115.00
Huggy Wuggy EXE, Poppy Playtime Plush, Horror Doll
Etsy
40% off
$69.00
$115.00
Huggy Wuggy EXE, Poppy Playtime Plush, Horror Doll
Etsy
$79.00
Horror Plush Bunny Creepy Plush Doll Boy Rabbit Halloween Doll Handmade
Etsy
48
Free shipping
$79.00
Horror Plush Bunny Creepy Plush Doll Boy Rabbit Halloween Doll Handmade
Etsy
$70.00
Tattletale - Creepy Teddy Bear, Creepy Plush, Creepy Doll, Horror Plush, Creepy Plushies, Creepy Cute, Creepy Decor, Scary Plushies
Etsy
Free shipping
$70.00
Tattletale - Creepy Teddy Bear, Creepy Plush, Creepy Doll, Horror Plush, Creepy Plushies, Creepy Cute, Creepy Decor, Scary Plushies
Etsy
$70.00
Parasite - Creepy Teddy Bear, Creepy Plush, Creepy Doll, Horror Plush, Creepy Plushies, Creepy Cute, Creepy Decor, Scary Plushies
Etsy
Free shipping
$70.00
Parasite - Creepy Teddy Bear, Creepy Plush, Creepy Doll, Horror Plush, Creepy Plushies, Creepy Cute, Creepy Decor, Scary Plushies
Etsy
$64.46
Creepy Horror Scary Teddy Bear Disturbing Spooky Haunted Stuffed Animal Toy Terrifying Frightening Monster Eye Head Handmade Plushie Unique
Etsy
$64.46
Creepy Horror Scary Teddy Bear Disturbing Spooky Haunted Stuffed Animal Toy Terrifying Frightening Monster Eye Head Handmade Plushie Unique
Etsy
$46.24
Creepy Horror Teddy Bear - Unique Halloween Decor - Handcrafted Scary Teddy Bear
Etsy
$46.24
Creepy Horror Teddy Bear - Unique Halloween Decor - Handcrafted Scary Teddy Bear
Etsy
$60.00
Custom Creepy Horror Teddy Bear Plush, Horror Plush
Etsy
$60.00
Custom Creepy Horror Teddy Bear Plush, Horror Plush
Etsy
$74.50
Scary Teddy Bear - Upcycled Horror Collectors Item - Unique Halloween Decor - One-Of-A-Kind Creepy Horror Teddy Bear
Etsy
$74.50
Scary Teddy Bear - Upcycled Horror Collectors Item - Unique Halloween Decor - One-Of-A-Kind Creepy Horror Teddy Bear
Etsy
$70.00
Creepy Horror Colorful Heart Half Head Bear Stuffed Toy 16", Horror Plush
Etsy
$70.00
Creepy Horror Colorful Heart Half Head Bear Stuffed Toy 16", Horror Plush
Etsy
$80.00
Sugar Plum - Creepy Teddy Bear, Creepy Plush, Creepy Doll, Horror Plush, Creepy Plushies, Creepy Cute, Creepy Decor, Scary Plushies
Etsy
Free shipping
$80.00
Sugar Plum - Creepy Teddy Bear, Creepy Plush, Creepy Doll, Horror Plush, Creepy Plushies, Creepy Cute, Creepy Decor, Scary Plushies
Etsy
$49.45
Horror Teddy Bear - Scary Collectible - One-Of-A-Kind Creep Teddy Bear - Recycled Plush Monster
Etsy
$49.45
Horror Teddy Bear - Scary Collectible - One-Of-A-Kind Creep Teddy Bear - Recycled Plush Monster
Etsy
$55.00
Custom Creepy Bloody White Bear Stuffed Toys, Horror Plush
Etsy
$55.00
Custom Creepy Bloody White Bear Stuffed Toys, Horror Plush
Etsy
$67.15
Creepy Cute Plush Bunny Doll Horror Plushies Ugly Doll Plush Rabbit
Etsy
49
Free shipping
$67.15
Creepy Cute Plush Bunny Doll Horror Plushies Ugly Doll Plush Rabbit
Etsy
$59.09
Horror Teddy Bear - Scary Collectible Handcrafted Bear - Unique Halloween Decor - Upcycled Horror Collectors Item
Etsy
$59.09
Horror Teddy Bear - Scary Collectible Handcrafted Bear - Unique Halloween Decor - Upcycled Horror Collectors Item
Etsy
$82.00
Handmade Zombie Bears Horror Creepyart Plush Bloody Teddybear Braindead
Etsy
$82.00
Handmade Zombie Bears Horror Creepyart Plush Bloody Teddybear Braindead
Etsy
$70.54
Scary Dog Plush - Creepy Plush - Horror Plush - Scary Plush - Gothic Decor - Halloween - Scary Teddy Bear
Etsy
Free shipping
$70.54
Scary Dog Plush - Creepy Plush - Horror Plush - Scary Plush - Gothic Decor - Halloween - Scary Teddy Bear
Etsy
$45.00
Horror Teddy Bear 3
Etsy
$45.00
Horror Teddy Bear 3
Etsy
$74.50
Gory Scary Horror Teddy Bear - Upcycled Spooky Plush - Scary Collectible - Unique Halloween Decor - One-Of-A-Kind Creepy Teddy Bear
Etsy
$74.50
Gory Scary Horror Teddy Bear - Upcycled Spooky Plush - Scary Collectible - Unique Halloween Decor - One-Of-A-Kind Creepy Teddy Bear
Etsy
$30.00
Custom Horror Very Hungry Caterpillar Stuffed Toys
Etsy
$30.00
Custom Horror Very Hungry Caterpillar Stuffed Toys
Etsy
$50.00
Bearifier: Art The Clown Inspired Creepy Teddy Bear - Horror Collectible Plush
Etsy
25
$50.00
Bearifier: Art The Clown Inspired Creepy Teddy Bear - Horror Collectible Plush
Etsy
$3,061.88
Maned Wolf Realistic Toy Stuffed Animal Replica Wild Golden Dog Faux Fur Taxidermy Live Size Made To Orden
Etsy
9
Free shipping
$3,061.88
Maned Wolf Realistic Toy Stuffed Animal Replica Wild Golden Dog Faux Fur Taxidermy Live Size Made To Orden
Etsy
$35.00
Teddy Bear / Creepy Doll / Creepy Plushie / Horror Plushie / Stuffed Bear/ Horror Doll/ Gore Doll/ Horror Decor
Etsy
Free shipping
$35.00
Teddy Bear / Creepy Doll / Creepy Plushie / Horror Plushie / Stuffed Bear/ Horror Doll/ Gore Doll/ Horror Decor
Etsy
$64.46
Cute Creepy Doll Scary Plush Weird Stuffed Toy
Etsy
$64.46
Cute Creepy Doll Scary Plush Weird Stuffed Toy
Etsy
$64.09
Laughing Jack Plush Creepypasta Every Doll Is Unique
Etsy
$64.09
Laughing Jack Plush Creepypasta Every Doll Is Unique
Etsy
$77.07
Custom Horror Teddy Bear - Upcycled Spooky Plush - Scary Collectible - Unique Halloween Decor - One-Of-A-Kind Gorey Creepy Teddy Bear
Etsy
$77.07
Custom Horror Teddy Bear - Upcycled Spooky Plush - Scary Collectible - Unique Halloween Decor - One-Of-A-Kind Gorey Creepy Teddy Bear
Etsy
$44.44
$72.86
Lemon Demon Monster Plush Friday Night Funkin Inspired, 11.8 In, Made To Order
Etsy
11K+
39% off
$44.44
$72.86
Lemon Demon Monster Plush Friday Night Funkin Inspired, 11.8 In, Made To Order
Etsy
See more
See less
    Some results have been hidden because they may be inaccessible to you.Show inaccessible results
    See more images

    Shop scary stuffed animals

    Sponsored
    $14.99
    Horror Baby, Horror Rattles, Baby Plushie, Stuffy, Jason, Friday, 13Th, Halloween, Cult Horror, Halloween, Scary, Horror Fan, Babyshower
    Etsy
    1K+
    $14.99
    Horror Baby, Horror Rattles, Baby Plushie, Stuffy, Jason, Friday, 13Th, Halloween, Cult Horror, Halloween, Scary, Horror Fan, Babyshower
    Etsy
    $14.99
    Horror Baby, Horror Rattles, Baby Plushie, Stuffy, Penny, Clown, Classic, Halloween, Cult Horror, Halloween, Scary, Horror Fan, Babyshower
    Etsy
    1K+
    $14.99
    Horror Baby, Horror Rattles, Baby Plushie, Stuffy, Penny, Clown, Classic, Halloween, Cult Horror, Halloween, Scary, Horror Fan, Babyshower
    Etsy
    $16.20
    40cm Huggy Wuggy Horror Doll Plush Toy | Blue
    DailySale
    $16.20
    40cm Huggy Wuggy Horror Doll Plush Toy | Blue
    DailySale
    $99.00
    Huggy Wuggy 32", Poppy Playtime Plush, Horror Doll, Monster Plush, Creepy Plush, Weirdcore Plush, Giant Plush, Big Plush
    Etsy
    $99.00
    Huggy Wuggy 32", Poppy Playtime Plush, Horror Doll, Monster Plush, Creepy Plush, Weirdcore Plush, Giant Plush, Big Plush
    Etsy
    $69.00
    Custom Creepy Horror Carebear Stuffed Toys, Horror Plush
    Etsy
    $69.00
    Custom Creepy Horror Carebear Stuffed Toys, Horror Plush
    Etsy
    $86.70
    $102.00
    Honeysuckles- Creepy Plush Bear,Creepy Oddities, Horror Dolls, Macabre Gift, Zombie Animal, Creepy Toy,Gothic Toys,Weird Plushies,Scary Gift
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    15% off
    $86.70
    $102.00
    Honeysuckles- Creepy Plush Bear,Creepy Oddities, Horror Dolls, Macabre Gift, Zombie Animal, Creepy Toy,Gothic Toys,Weird Plushies,Scary Gift
    Etsy
    $48.00
    Custom Creepy Horror Carebear Stuffed Toys, Horror Plush
    Etsy
    $48.00
    Custom Creepy Horror Carebear Stuffed Toys, Horror Plush
    Etsy
    $82.00
    Handmade Zombie Bears Horror Creepyart Plush Bloody Teddybear Brain
    Etsy
    $82.00
    Handmade Zombie Bears Horror Creepyart Plush Bloody Teddybear Brain
    Etsy
    $71.40
    $84.00
    Chipper- Creepy Plush Bear,Creepy Oddities, Horror Dolls, Macabre Gift, Zombie Animal, Creepy Toy,Gothic Toys,Weird Plushies,Scary Gift
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    14% off
    $71.40
    $84.00
    Chipper- Creepy Plush Bear,Creepy Oddities, Horror Dolls, Macabre Gift, Zombie Animal, Creepy Toy,Gothic Toys,Weird Plushies,Scary Gift
    Etsy
    $100.00
    MADE TO ORDER Creepy Cute Horror Cuddly Plushies
    Etsy
    $100.00
    MADE TO ORDER Creepy Cute Horror Cuddly Plushies
    Etsy
    $69.00
    $115.00
    Huggy Wuggy EXE, Poppy Playtime Plush, Horror Doll
    Etsy
    40% off
    $69.00
    $115.00
    Huggy Wuggy EXE, Poppy Playtime Plush, Horror Doll
    Etsy
    $79.00
    Horror Plush Bunny Creepy Plush Doll Boy Rabbit Halloween Doll Handmade
    Etsy
    48
    Free shipping
    $79.00
    Horror Plush Bunny Creepy Plush Doll Boy Rabbit Halloween Doll Handmade
    Etsy
    $70.00
    Tattletale - Creepy Teddy Bear, Creepy Plush, Creepy Doll, Horror Plush, Creepy Plushies, Creepy Cute, Creepy Decor, Scary Plushies
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    $70.00
    Tattletale - Creepy Teddy Bear, Creepy Plush, Creepy Doll, Horror Plush, Creepy Plushies, Creepy Cute, Creepy Decor, Scary Plushies
    Etsy
    $70.00
    Parasite - Creepy Teddy Bear, Creepy Plush, Creepy Doll, Horror Plush, Creepy Plushies, Creepy Cute, Creepy Decor, Scary Plushies
    Etsy
    Free shipping
    $70.00
    Parasite - Creepy Teddy Bear, Creepy Plush, Creepy Doll, Horror Plush, Creepy Plushies, Creepy Cute, Creepy Decor, Scary Plushies
    Etsy
    $64.46
    Creepy Horror Scary Teddy Bear Disturbing Spooky Haunted Stuffed Animal Toy Terrifying Frightening Monster Eye Head Handmade Plushie Unique
    Etsy
    $64.46
    Creepy Horror Scary Teddy Bear Disturbing Spooky Haunted Stuffed Animal Toy Terrifying Frightening Monster Eye Head Handmade Plushie Unique
    Etsy
    $46.24
    Creepy Horror Teddy Bear - Unique Halloween Decor - Handcrafted Scary Teddy Bear
    Etsy
    $46.24
    Creepy Horror Teddy Bear - Unique Halloween Decor - Handcrafted Scary Teddy Bear
    Etsy
    $60.00
    Custom Creepy Horror Teddy Bear Plush, Horror Plush
    Etsy
    $60.00
    Custom Creepy Horror Teddy Bear Plush, Horror Plush
    Etsy
    $74.50
    Scary Teddy Bear - Upcycled Horror Collectors Item - Unique Halloween Decor - One-Of-A-Kind Creepy Horror Teddy Bear
    Etsy
    $74.50
    Scary Teddy Bear - Upcycled Horror Collectors Item - Unique Halloween Decor - One-Of-A-Kind Creepy Horror Teddy Bear
    Etsy